Critos Argument Essay - 1379 Words

The purpose of amp;quot;Critoamp;quot; seems intended to exhibit the character of Socrates in one light only, not as the philosopher, fulfilling a divine mission and trusting in the will of Heaven, but simply as the good citizen, who, having been unjustly condemned is willing to give up his life in obedience to the laws of the State. The main argument that seems to entail the discussion between Crito and Socrates is the opinion of the majority on Socrates’ fate. In the amp;quot;Critoamp;quot; Socrates states, amp;quot;Why should we care so much for what the majority think?amp;quot; (Plato 45) Socrates believes that we should not care what the majority thinks because those who are reasonable people will understand. However,†¦show more content†¦Crito refutes claiming that [his] decision is not right, giving up [his] life when he could save it, and to hasten [his] fate as his enemies would hasten it and indeed have hastened it in their wish to destroy [him] (Plato 46). amp;#9;In addition to Socrates’ position on the devotion and faith he has given to the state of Athens Socrates’ also has a position regarding the role of the majority in his decision not to escape. Socrates believes that amp;quot;fate has come about me†¦I shall not agree with you, not even if the power of the majority were to frighten us with more bogeys, as if we were children, with threats of incarcerations and executions and confiscation of property†¦.Crito, whether this argument will appear any different in any way different to me in my present circumstances, or whether it remains the same, whether we are to abandon it or believe itamp;quot; (Plato 46-47). In this case Socrates is saying that regardless of what the situation may be he is standing forthright in his decision to face his death. Socrates is trying to explain to Crito that even if he is trying to bully him into exile it will not work. Crito says that Socrates is making a cowardly move by facin g death, whereas Socrates believes that he is the one who will end up the stronger man in the end. I think the point Socrates is trying to get across is that regardless of how the current situation is phrased, or even if you were to ignore the present situation completely—it allShow MoreRelatedThe Argument On Crito And Socrates Debate817 Words   |  4 Pagesshould flee his execution and how Socrates thinks on his arguments. The Global argument on Crito has two parts. The first half assumes fleeing is morally wrong and draws out the consequences of Socrates fleeing if the moral experts saw it as such. The second half follows up on the assumption that fleeing is morally wrong and that Socrates would be morally wrong if he was to flee. Crito pressed Socrates with a multitude of different arguments that he had hoped would convince him to flee his executionRead MoreSocrates Views On Plato s Dialogue856 Words   |  4 Pagesbelief that you should never commit an injustice act for any reason, and that it is in your best interest to act justly. In the arguments presented in â€Å"Crito,† we see Socrates’ belief as underlying factor and recurring theme. Crito goes to see Socrates and starts by letting him know that he cares about him, then proceeds to spew out all of his arguments. The first argument brought up was that he will ruin the reputation of his friends and family. His reasoning being that if people saw Crito and knewRead MoreThe Argument In The Crito By Socrates762 Words   |  4 PagesThe Crito Analysis In The Crito by Socrates, both Crito and Socrates present arguments, one that Socrates should escape prison, and one that he should not. Crito’s argument contains logic fallacies that undermine his argument and make it weak. Therefore, Socrates argument that he should remain in prison and face his death is valid and strong, and is better than Crito’s. Crito argues that Socrates should escape jail, and relies on the premises that he must consider the opinion of the public andRead MoreAnalysis Of The Book The Of Socrates 1223 Words   |  5 Pagespart, since we did not save you, or you save yourself, when it was possible† (45e-46e). This quote from the text Crito, written by Plato, directly illustrates Crito’s claim of feeling ashamed on Socrates’ behalf and on behalf of his friends, if what happened was due to cowardice on their part. In order for us to be able to validate this argument as persuasive or not, we must first take a look at the definitions of courage and manliness. Plato more clearly discusses these attributes of courage and manlinessRead MoreThe Rational Vs. The Emotional1573 Words   |  7 Pagesreasons for staying in jail. Crito’s argument for Socrates to escape from jail are more emotion driven which makes them less logical and credible; on the other hand, Socrates provides more credible and logical reasons for staying because his arguments are not emotion driven. To start off, Crito’s arguments have less ethos than Socrates’ arguments. This is mainly because Crito is basing his arguments off his emotions for his friend. One example that shows how Crito’s emotions are affecting his insightRead MoreSocrates s Argument On The Trial867 Words   |  4 Pagesallegations and sentence to death. While waiting for his upcoming execution, he received a visit of his old faithful friend named Crito. Actually, Socrates friend had made an arrangement with other friends to help him escape from prison. Contrary to Crito’s suggestion, Socrates vetoed his friend proposal. Socrates on the other hand, provided several good and convincing reasons of not escaping prison by using law as a principal guide. After the trial, Socrates was sentenced to death for impietyRead More Crito Essay827 Words   |  4 Pagesthat it is just to escape from prison to avoid certain death by execution. Socrates argument directly relates to the laws of the state and the role of the individual within it. The quot;Critoquot; exhibits the character of Socrates as a good citizen, who being unjustly condemned is willing to give up his life in obedience to the laws of the State. This report will discuss the major elements in Socrates argument, regarding the injury and injustice he would cause by escaping from prison prior toRead MoreTrial of Socrates914 Words   |  4 Pagesnumerous opportunities to evade the death penalty, he does not seem interested in pursuing those options. When he is convicted and put in jail, he has many opportunities to escape from prison. Crito offers three arguments to try and convince Socrates to escape but Socrates counters all of Crito’s points. I believe that Socrates did not escape from prison after being convicted because he wanted to cement his legacy and beliefs through his death. Socrates believed that he was sent to Athens by theRead MoreEssay on Crito by Plato869 Words   |  4 Pagesafter Socrates is condemned to death and sitting in his jail cell. Crito is Socrates good friend and has come to visit Socrates in the hopes of convincing his old friend to escape. But Socrates logically refutes Critos argument. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Crito begins his argument by bringing bad news to Socrates, relating to him that the ship from Delos is approaching and, with it, the hour of his mandated death. Socrates seems resigned to his fated death, but Crito attempts to persuade himRead MoreThe Role Of Crito 1204 Words   |  5 PagesCrito tells Socrates that he and other Athenians cannot stand the thought of Socrates dying, therefore â€Å"it is not much money that some people require to save [him] and get [him] out of [there]† (Crito 40). Socrates denies his offer and shuts down Crito’s resistance, giving him a long speech as to why he must die nobly in Athens. Crito continues to try and persuade Socrates to escape, reminding him of the family, friends and followers he has in Athens. Crito warns Socrates that if he dies he will